In Re RM Application for Judicial Review (Northern Ireland) [2024] UKSC 7, the provisions of the Mental Health Order (Northern Ireland) 1986 came… Read more
Category: Case comments
Scottish Guardianship Orders, Deprivation of Liberty and Article 5 ECHR: a serious cross-border concern
In Aberdeenshire Council v SF (No 2) [2024] EWCOP 10, Poole J took the very unusual step of declining to… Read more
Contact, contraception, conception and conceptual clarity: Poole J dissects a difficult question
Poole J is rapidly becoming the specialist sexual capacity judge at the Court of Protection. Following his decisions in Hull… Read more
Triangulation and flexibility: taking capacity seriously in changing circumstances
Re DY [2024] EWCOP 4 is a case showing how demanding taking capacity seriously is – and should be. It… Read more
Don’t ignore the Serious Medical Treatment Guidance – but let’s be clear about what the law requires
This is a post co-written by Tor Butler-Cole KC and I, prompted by the decision in GUP v EUP and… Read more
LPAs – the duties on the certificate provider
In a case from December 2023 which arrived on Bailii too late for the February 2024 Mental Capacity Report, Lieven… Read more
We all die: what are doctors’ duties to shield families from the sight of death?
In Paul and another v Royal Wolverhampton NHS Trust [2024] UKSC 1, the Supreme Court had to decide whether (and,… Read more
The European Court of Human Rights: mental health detention and Articles 3 and 5 ECHR
Strasbourg means what it says in relation to the tightening of the criteria for admission and detention in the context… Read more
Court of Protection round-up: December/January
In lieu of a Mental Capacity Report, the next edition of which will be out in February, and which will… Read more
Capacity in context – a paradigm case
A Local Authority v KP [2023] EHWC 3210 (Fam) is a case not easily reducible to a short summary. In… Read more